Monday, 23 June 2008

Truth and untruth in Nepal

Today my colleague Shailaja was telling me how a young lady that the Trust is about to assist has come up with three very differing stories regarding her background and predicament - no need to go into the details of her case and all the stories are probably rubbish anyway. I report this merely to illustrate how difficult it is to conduct field work in Nepal and get to the bottom of things.

You could unkindly label this as being a problem of endemic lying but never make the mistake of calling a Nepali a liar. That's not culturally acceptable even if the evidence to that effect is crystal clear. This apparently dishonest behaviour seems to be more a case of a question posed receiving a number of different answers to see which is most palatable to the inquirer. Or a process of testing which reply is most likely to be suitable to get someone out of a tight spot even if his or her range of answers undermines belief in any of them. I think this all illustrates a kind of emotional immaturity that seems to be commonplace within Nepalese society and which is reflected in a range of other behavioural patterns (e.g. the rampant teasing of animals and children).

Given this trend it is remarkable that anyone passes a school examination that requires straight answers to straight questions. But today I learn that 64% of Nepalese 16 year olds (ish) passed The School Leavers Certificate (SLC) examination that was sat in April. This examination is the passport to higher education; those who fail are condemned to a life of manual labour and low income jobs. Amongst their number this year was young Bina Paudel, the first of our refuge children to pass the examination, doing so at "second division" (passes are graded into four categories - distinction, first, second and third). Bina has been staying at our Bhairahawa refuge but in recognition of her success and through the generous support of an anonymous UK sponsor she'll now be transferring to Kathmandu to start college. Two years hence I expect she'll set an example to her younger brothers and sisters by progressing to university and the prospect of a profession. I am very proud of her indeed.

Friday, 20 June 2008

The answer to Nepal's corruption

In my post of 11th June I described Minister for Forest and Soil Conservation Matrika Prasad Yadav as being "controversial"; perhaps in the light of the latest news this was rather an uncharacteristic understatement on my part. For Yadav is now at the centre of a storm of protest.

The problem began a few days ago when Yadav locked Lalitpur Local Development Officer Dandu Raj Ghimire in a Ministry toilet for one and a half hours. One might suspect that this bizarre behaviour could be a consequence of this Maoist minister still feeling flushed with his party's success in the recent elections. However in reality it was in response to Ghimire allowing an illegal quarry to continue to operate in a forest area in spite of a ban on the activity being imposed by Yadav. Ghimire has taken exception to the Minister's unorthodox action and civil servants have been on strike in his support, protesting Yadav's behaviour that has been described by some as being "harsh and unbecoming", by others as "inhuman and unlawful". The protestors have demanded a public apology (a popular outcry in this part of the world) or worse protests will follow. A defiant Yadav has responded by declaring that a toilet was the only right place for "corrupt and anti-environment persons".

I do have to wonder if a large part of the indignation is due to Yadav being an ethnic Indian (Madhesi) having had the temerity to humiliate a true blue ethnic Nepali (and a Brahmin to boot) like Ghimire - the protesting civil servants will be by and large themselves also be ethnic Nepalis. I could never condone the denial of someone's freedom without the involvement of the police, but in Yadav's defence at least the unfortunate Ghimire's detention was not entirely "inhuman" as at it didn't risk putting him in a tight spot in respect of a call of nature. And it has inspired me to propose a totally original solution to the problem of Nepal's widespread corruption...

Build bigger toilets.

Thursday, 19 June 2008

Raid on the Raj Mahal Circus

Here is the film I shot of last Friday's raid on The Raj Mahal Circus in Maharashtra State, southern India.

Wednesday, 18 June 2008

Miss Nepal

An advertisement and application form for the Miss Nepal 2008 competition appears on the back page of today's Himalayan Times newspaper. It states that candidates should be "attractive" (that seems to make some kind of sense) and of "good moral character". After advising that only women in the age range of 19-25 should apply there is a space for the parent's signature to indicate that they have no objection to their daughter participating in the competition. This strikes me as being arguably a little prissy while hundreds of Nepali girls whose parents couldn't care less are trafficked into the sex trade either across the border into India or to the tourist hotspots of Kathmandu.

Equally surreal was my spotting at the weekend an anti child labour poster inside The Raj Mahal Circus (see my post of 16th June) in the midst of the Circus's gross abuse and exploitation of child performers. This was a cunning attempt to deceive their public, but then again perhaps those circus people are not quite so clever as they think they are. I learned last evening that through our efforts the Raj Mahal's manager is now in jail pending investigation of his use of child/bonded labour.

Tuesday, 17 June 2008

Travel tips for India

Or more accurately what to avoid...

Let's start with Akola, Maharashtra State, in the south of India which is where the ill-fated Raj Mahal Circus was playing (see yesterday's post). I looked very hard when I was there to see anything that was remotely interesting either aesthetically or historically. To no avail. But if you happen to pass through by ill chance I would steer well clear of "The Venus International Hotel". You can spot it by the very grim concrete toadstools that are sprouting from flower beds outside its front windows. Even more tacky is the relief sculpture to be found behind reception. After you've checked in you'll find that the sculpture foreshadows even worse to come. In spite of the "International" name in its title the hotel doesn't offer international phone calls so when I was there I couldn't phone home to Nepal. The restaurant is geared for a vegan diet so cautious omnivores can't even opt for one of the safer dietary bets in India, the plain omelette for breakfast. The greatest horror though is that the hotel doesn't serve alcohol in spite of the wine glasses that appear enticingly in the aforementioned relief sculpture. The only consolation I could take from the long hours spent on the circus rescue at the end of last week was the small amount of residual time that was left to me to spend at the hotel.

I suppose there's not much chance of you passing through Akola (and I expect less so now after reading this post) however if you travel to India it's hard to avoid visiting Delhi airport. It is a real mess at the moment as the airport is being rebuilt to a grandiose design. Signboards everywhere request the visitor's understanding of any inconvenience with the promise of a better tomorrow. I remain unconvinced by this prospect as in spite of an improvement in airport infrastructure the problem will remain of the facilities being continued to be used by Air India. The ineptitude of Air India beggars belief. On the return trip from Akola I took a domestic flight with them from Nagpur to Delhi before connecting with the onward flight to Kathmandu. My suitcase was delivered to me absolutely soaked through. When I complained to the head of the baggage handlers (the highly indifferent, unblinking Ms Sangeeta Bawa) she told me that this was a result of heavy rain. It's not as if the monsoon is an unexpected arrival in this part of the world, but aside from that point of detail, I asserted that the state of my luggage was because Air India had failed to care for it properly in the inclement weather. She refused to accept this, but the picture I took shortly afterwards (right) of Air India baggage handlers operating in the pouring rain shows who was right and who was being downright dishonest.

I can't get too upset about damage to material things - although you will be relieved to learn that my suitcase seemed to dry out satisfactorily in the end. What bothers me is the indifference shown by people like the baggage handlers and Ms Bawa to their fellows. While I have come across many fantastic people in India (some were with me on the rescue mission) there seem at times to be many more who don't give two hoots about anyone else in that populous society. That is not far removed from the mentality of the trafficker and for that matter of those who elect to do nothing to right the wrongs of society. While this mentality remains extant those of us who are fighting trafficking will continue to do so as part of an uphill battle.

Monday, 16 June 2008

Raid on The Raj Mahal Circus

I have a confession and apology to make. In my posts of last week I wrote that I would be going to a circus rescue operation near Calcutta. This was a deliberate piece of misinformation, just in the (albeit unlikely) eventuality that someone with links to the Indian circus industry might be numbered amongst my readers. Instead the plan was to go to The Raj Mahal Circus which was playing at Akola, near Nagpur in central southern India. We wanted to be sure of total suprise so we didn't inform the child performers' families beforehand (often in the past someone from the families has tipped off the circus) and I decided to mislead through this Blog if I possibly could. Sorry about that...

We had a score to settle with this particular circus as a previous rescue attempt last year had failed (see my posts of 19th/20th August) due to indifference - and most likely the corruption - of the local authorities in the region in which it had been playing at the time. Moreover the Raj Mahal Circus is one of the four circuses owned by Fateh Khan who is the most exploitative of all the circus owners. His son, Raza, is currently facing rape charges for offences at one of his other circuses. Fateh Khan is a very dangerous man and recently he has further empowered himself by taking a leading role in North Indian politics.

I left on Thursday lunchtime, accompanied by journalist Pranaya Rana and photographer Min Ratna Bajracharya of the Nepali Times. We flew to Nagpur via Delhi, and in the end also via Hyderabad as monsoon weather in Nagpur prevented us from landing there initially. Eventually we got to Nagpur and drove through the night to join the rest of the team in Akola at 5.30 a.m. on Friday morning. Meeting Kelvin Symon of ChildLine India Foundation I was told that we would be going to the police at 6.30, one hour later; the police would raid the circus at 7.00 a.m. He was quietly confident of success, following the clear cooperation that the advance party had received from the authorities over the previous few days. Kelvin was already beaming with pleasure as he had been part of the team that had been rebuffed last August and revenge would be sweet.

The raid went like a dream with 20 performers being released without any resistance. Of these 17 were female. One of the males was 43 years old; he had gone to the circus to find work and they wouldn't let him leave again so we readily agreed that he could walk out through the gates with us as well. Of the 20 releasees, 13 were minors (under 18). Six releasees were from Nepal itself and the remainder were (mainly ethnic Nepali) Indian nationals from West Bengal.

Raids always throw up surprises in what one finds and this time a big surprise came in the form of the presence of two foreign female performers, one American the other Italian, who were on short contracts. When I chatted to them it was clear that they had no idea of what was going on around them. They were kept largely separate from the rest of the troupe and allowed to leave the circus to go into town. They didn't know of the rape and violence of the Kahn circuses and never heard of Fateh Khan. Nor did they realise that the other girls weren't being paid. One of them asked me what the attraction of Nepalese girls was and when I said it was their fair skin I could see the penny drop with her. A white girl in a leotard is a great crowd puller for all the wrong reasons.

A key element to the success of the operation was the presence of a barrister, Nandita Rao, on the team. She ensured that everything was done by the book and in accordance with Indian law which is crystal clear on the definition and management of child labour and bonded labour. All of the releasees were modern day slaves and now that the paperwork to that effect has been completed meticulously under Nandita's supervision I am quite confident that the circus owner, Fateh Khan, will go to prison for his crimes.

The circus had been taken entirely by surprise which is perhaps why the raid was so unopposed. But later on in the day one of Khan's brothers turned up on a motor bike outside the police station and threatened some of the team members. The feisty Nandita Rao chased him off telling him that he'd better leave quickly or she would report him to the police for attempting to interrupt a police investigation. For the remainder of the day circus people watched us from jeeps and motor bikes in a continued attempt to intimidate us. In their number was one guy whom my colleague Shailaja (who was on the August 2007 rescue) remembered as having threatened to kill her if she returned to the circus. In spite of all this posturing we knew that we were safe as the police were on our side. Instead we were rather amused that the circus had been so unsettled by our success and no doubt also by the prospect of criminal convictions.

This week all of the releasees will be returned home with a police escort the whole way to their final destination to prevent circus retaliation or abduction. Then we'll help them to rejoin the human race. One girl showed us the marks on her hands which followed cuts received from the trapeze act having been cauterised by the ringmaster using molten wax so that the show could go on. His sordid show is now doomed to close forever.

I feel very proud to have been part of this operation, especially seeing the dedication and commitment of my colleagues. Over those couple of days the team members ate little or no food and worked around the clock. I have an abiding memory of seeing Nandita sleeping in the open in the midst of all the girls in a police courtyard. She told me afterwards that she is immune to the mosquitoes that were devouring the rest of us. Below I publish some film that I shot of the girls leaving the circus for good. I will edit my film footage over the next few days and publish a fuller version towards the end of the week.


Wednesday, 11 June 2008

Farewell to Holly

Today I invited volunteer Holly Wheaton, who is due to leave the team on Friday, for a farewell lunch. Holly is a gap year student who has been taking a year out prior to going to Warwick University in the UK this September. Many gap year students elect to travel around the world enjoying a prolonged holiday after school. Personally though, I think that this crucial time is better spent in character-forming activities if appropriate challenges can be found. Holly has had just such an experience in that we placed her for several months in a remote part of Nepal (Bhairahawa) and asked her to help teach deaf school leavers mosaic art. She rose to that challenge and has been outstanding; she's enjoyed herself immensely as well.

Everyone will miss Holly over here and we look forward to her keeping her promise to come back to Nepal next Summer.